Accrued pension benefits cannot be reduced
Issue: Your company is considering making changes to its pension plan in an effort to cut costs. May your company amend its plan if the amendment results in a reduction in accrued benefits?
Answer:     No. The accrued benefits of plan participants generally may not be eliminated or decreased by plan amendments (known as the "anti-cutback rule"). A plan amendment that has the effect of eliminating or reducing an early retirement benefit or a retirement-type subsidy, or eliminating an optional form of benefit with respect to benefits attributable to service before the plan amendment, is treated as reducing accrued benefits.

A plan may be amended to eliminate or reduce protected benefits that have not accrued as of the date the amendment is adopted or made effective. In addition, a plan amendment may eliminate or reduce protected benefits that have already accrued, if:
  • the amendment is adopted to enable the plan to comply with a change in law affecting plan qualification;
  • the reduction or elimination of an accrued benefit is necessary to enable the plan to retain tax qualified status; and
  • the Commissioner of the IRS authorizes relief under Code Sec. 7805(b).

Benefits that may be reduced. Some other types of benefits are not protected from reduction or elimination. A qualified plan may be amended to reduce or eliminate:
  • ancillary life insurance protection;
  • accident or health insurance benefits;
  • certain Social Security supplements;
  • the availability of loans (other than the distribution of an employee's accrued benefit upon loan default);
  • the right to make after-tax employee contributions or elective deferrals;
  • the right to direct investments;
  • the right to a form of investment (such as employer stock or securities);
  • the right to allocation dates for contributions, forfeitures and earnings, the time for making contributions, and the valuation date for account balances;
  • the right to receive hardship distributions; and
  • rights relating to the administration and operation of the plan.

Source: CCH U.S. Master Pension Guide
[ Return to top of document ]